Though we’re not living in normal times or circumstances currently, summertime for students studying in colleges and universities usually means internships. Proper internship programs in Pakistan are limited and most interns are required to work free of cost and are promised “exposure and experience” in return. Recently, Pakistani Twitter was lit with a debate on unpaid internships with netizens demanding a ban on them.
The debate started when an old tweet resurfaced in which a Twitter user had called out a prominent influencer for promoting unpaid internships and had mocked them.
The internship advertisement posted by Syed Muzammil Hasan Zaidi stated that he needed an intern/assistant to work on several projects with him. He clarified that the position is unpaid and that the successful candidate will get no leaves for three months. Incentives included getting a chance to work with top government officials and top creators in the digital media industry.
Following that, Twitter users began to slam the influencer for promoting this and called for the culture of unpaid internships to be cancelled.
So basically what he's saying is, those of you who are under privileged don't even bother applying, because not only do I don't want you guys around me I will also not pay you not to forget I'll be hard on you.
— Mustafa T. Wynne (@mustafa_wynne) July 2, 2020
It is criminal to ask for work without giving any remuneration, it is exploitation. I hate it.
— Mahwash Ajaz (@mahwashajaz_) July 2, 2020
Ok bye. https://t.co/NB6TW56CdL
Manage your own transport, and no pay. Rule of thumb in professional world is never do anything for free. When will these people realize? They are from our generation and exploiting the youngsters themselves like this?? https://t.co/STPTPafnzK
— Sidra Aziz (@NamkeenJalebi) July 2, 2020
I need an intern that will look after my child, do the dishes, clean. Commute everyday themselves in corona times. Put their health at risk. And remember, I will treat you horribly. No pay, but you get exposure in cleaning. Opportunity of a lifetime ???#influencerstoday #sayno
— Maheen Ghani (@maheenghani_) July 3, 2020
It used to irk me at my previous jobs that any travel – local or otherwise was at MY expense.
— Manahyl (@manahylk) July 3, 2020
While I worked as an editor at a magazine, I routinely had to send my driver to collect things from all over the city with zero compensation.
Terrible. Infact, these young "influencers" (yes, I say that mockingly) should influence/speak up for- just off the top of my head- labor rights, workers compensation, minimum wage, unfair labor practices… Start by setting an example. That's the kind of influencing we need https://t.co/dHebgbecUC
— Huma Sattar (@SattarHuma) July 3, 2020
I need an unpaid intern who wakes up before me, makes me a paratha every morning, stays silent when I am working, does everything in the blink od eye, and never dares asking me a salary. Incentive: EXPOSURE, LEARNING, NETWORKING
— Saadia Ahmed (@khwamkhwah) July 3, 2020
*stay away from any such offers, young people*
There’s no such thing as an unpaid internship. Just say you’re exploiting labour and go ! https://t.co/RzBSDNB5ns
— ?ملیحہ? (@theD_inDNA) July 2, 2020
Internships without pay/stipend is the biggest scam of human history. That's it#exploitation
— Zaafir Javed Ahmed (@ZaafirJaved) July 2, 2020
All of this is super exploitative. https://t.co/GmyiTrLFFG
— Syed M. Saad Ahsan (@saadahsan) July 2, 2020
So basically: I am going to make your life miserable. I won't pay you. You will have to pay for your transport yourself. I said it's an 8-hour job but I will make you work 24/7. I mentioned I might hire you permanently but there is no guarantee & I can get rid of you anytime. https://t.co/U1S8qXyWIL
— Alii (@Bhuut_) July 2, 2020
I wish I could go back in time and undo all my unpaid internships. So much anger. Such less value for work. Terrible bosses. Two most famous media houses. https://t.co/NamIC9hYHc
— Manal (@manalkhan07) July 2, 2020
When you are reaping the full benefits of someone’s skills and talent, YOU are not doing a favor to them. If they are competent enough to help your business in its goals, they sure as hell deserve fair monetary compensation for it
— Meshal Malik (@MeshalMalikk) July 3, 2020
Unpaid internship is slavery.
— Saadia Ahmed (@khwamkhwah) July 3, 2020
Unpaid internship + No travel allowance + No time off + Have to come daily to the office + Will dry grilled = Do this for 3 months and get a whopping RS15,000 a month when you get the final job. https://t.co/3X36TAO7vB
— Ted Schmosby (@BranTheBrokenn) July 3, 2020
The debate is not just limited to Pakistan. People across the world are calling for a ban on this practise and are urging workplaces to be more inclusive.
Unpaid internships should be illegal. They perpetuate inequities and do not recruit best/brightest- only those who can afford to go without pay. That especially includes @UN @WHO and other global institutions founded on human rights frameworks. https://t.co/0XERwFlvJl
— Natalia Rodriguez, PhD, MPH (@NataRodzJ) June 28, 2020
This, and unpaid internships, are why affluent white kids get a leg up on experience. They can afford these low-pay to no-pay jobs. They tack it on their resume & after 2 years level up.
— defund as a means to abolish (@awkward_duck) June 30, 2020
This exacerbates the racial wealth gap. Non-Profits that do this are a part of the problem. https://t.co/js4XxkjEbf