Famous Pakistani vloggers Rajab Butt, Ducky Bhai (Saad ur Rehman), and Nadeem Naniwala have launched a new learning platform called ‘Join Elite Group’. This platform offers paid courses on TikTok live streams, business startups, cryptocurrency investments, YouTube vlogging, and online store management. 

 

However, the project has faced significant backlash, with critics questioning its legitimacy and intentions.

 

Join Elite Group is an online platform designed to offer a variety of paid courses aimed at professionals, entrepreneurs, creatives, and enthusiasts. The courses cover a range of topics, including:

 

TikTok Live Streaming: Strategies and best practices for monetizing live streams.

Business Startups: Guidance on launching and managing businesses effectively.

Cryptocurrency Investments: Insights into trading and navigating the crypto market.

YouTube Growth: Techniques to start, grow, and sustain YouTube channels while boosting engagement.

E-commerce Expertise: Methods to establish and optimize online stores for increased sales.

 

Despite these ambitious offerings, the platform’s credibility has been called into question by a growing number of critics. 

 

Since its launch, the Join Elite Group website has struggled with technical problems. Users have reported high traffic issues, frequent "too many requests" errors, and difficulties signing up, which has fueled skepticism about the platform’s reliability and transparency.

 

Journalist Sheraz Butt, who has 496K followers on Instagram, recently criticized the project in a viral video. He questioned the integrity of the creators, saying:

 

"These are the same creators who sold their private lives like a reality show. Now they claim that they will teach the youth how to earn money?" YouTuber Sheraz also mocked their courses, adding:

 

"YouTube is a trend that may end in a year. Are they trying to make money now by selling courses on how to earn from YouTube? It’s laughable."

 

He argued that these creators gained fame by showcasing their families and private lives, and now they are monetizing their audience by selling knowledge that is freely available online.

 

Adding fuel to the fire, Ducky Bhai’s past remarks have resurfaced. In a podcast, he admitted, "I am not a teacher to provide knowledge."

However, while promoting the project, he stated, "You have supported us for years; now it’s our turn to give back and help you stand on your feet."

 

The criticism doesn’t stop there. Talha Reviews, another YouTuber, labeled the project a "scam." 

 

Similarly, popular YouTubers Maaz Safdar and Ali Butt advised fans to avoid the initiative, pointing out that free resources for learning about YouTube and online earning are readily available.

 

Many fans and critics alike have questioned the credibility of these courses, calling them a "fraud business."

 

Hundreds of YouTubers with global followings offer free seminars, courses and tips on how to grow online audiences. TikTok, Instagram, Twitter and nearly all social media platforms carry such content, easily searchable and in easy to understand terms.

 

Many Pakistanis too have posted such videos, offering breakdowns of algorithms and financial benefits, completely free of charge.