The Pakistan Cricket Board (PCB) and the Multan Sultans franchise have found themselves in a heated exchange ahead of the Pakistan Super League (PSL).

 

According to media reports, the PCB stated, "A franchise owner's statements ahead of the PSL are an attempt to create controversy around the tournament. The PSL Code of Conduct grants us the authority to take disciplinary action against franchise owners, but doing so at this stage could damage the league."

 

A senior PCB official added, "If anyone has complaints, they should reach out to us. Unfortunately, the person making these complaints does not even attend meetings. If he were present, these issues wouldn't arise. The PCB does not wish to engage in this dispute. Our decisions to elevate the league are transparent."

 

He further said, "We do not want to boast about our achievements, but for the first time, PSL commentary will be available in Urdu. We've also introduced advanced umpiring technology and made several other improvements. There is another league happening in our neighbouring country, and taking strict action at this time could harm the PSL's reputation."

 

Commenting on the recent controversy surrounding Ali Zafar's inclusion in the PSL anthem, the official remarked, "As soon as Ali Zafar's name was mentioned, statements were made without even waiting for the announcement of the remaining three names. The court has already dismissed the case against Ali Zafar, yet it was made controversial again.

 

Ali Tareen's Concerns and Criticism

 

Ali Tareen, the youngest PSL franchise owner, has raised serious questions about the PCB's league management, expressing his frustration.

 

He said, "We keep hearing that this is the biggest and best PSL ever. I am tired of these repeated claims. The current PSL management lacks seriousness. We, as team owners, have no long-term control over our teams. Before adding new teams, there needs to be a clear policy. Otherwise, the league's future will be at risk. The same six teams and four stadiums continue to host matches. Even last year, the final was decided on the last ball. I am not trying to disrespect anyone, but if they have a plan to expand the PSL, I would like to know about it."

 

Ali Tareen also questioned the PCB's approach to innovation. "It is disappointing to see how our most successful brand is being handled. Tell us what new things are being introduced this year compared to previous seasons. How is the PSL going to be bigger and more historic? At least make an effort, like the Big Bash League, which has made the game more exciting and attractive. The Big Bash introduced a four-over powerplay at the start, with the remaining two overs of the powerplay available for teams to take at any point. If there is no intention to introduce innovations, please stop making false claims."

 

Ali Tareen also criticised the current franchise model of the PSL, stating, "All franchises are currently operating on a 'rental model', where team owners do not have actual ownership rights. Every year, franchise owners pay a fee to retain their teams, but they do not own them. Unlike the Indian Premier League (IPL), we do not have opportunities for foreign investment."

 

Furthermore, he raised concerns about the league's expansion plans. "The PCB has yet to present a clear plan for expanding to eight teams for the 11th edition of the PSL. Similarly, if revenue-sharing issues arise, it will create an awkward situation. IPL team owners can sell their teams to anyone, with the board only assessing financial capability and management plans. We, however, do not even have that option," Ali said.

 

With PSL 2024 just around the corner, this public disagreement between the PCB and one of its franchise owners raises questions about the governance and long-term vision of the league. While the PSL continues to grow, the concerns highlighted by Ali Tareen suggest that significant structural and policy changes may be needed to ensure its sustainable success.